The book follows a lot more of their trip and all of the stops they make, but when they finally realize theyve been busted and have to come to terms with their relationship being in danger. The screenplay by phyllis nagy is based on the 1952 romance novel the price of salt by patricia highsmith republished as carol in 1990. For most of the trip, carol is in chargeshe is older, she has the money, she drives the car, and she has the map. A christmal carol 1951 movie and a christmas carol 1984 movie, with george c. The true love story behind the making of carol how a cult book based on a moment of romantic fantasy became the source of misguided shame for its author and one hothouse flower of a movie. Book is different from the movie, dark and a little scary private detective especially.
The true love story behind the making of carol rolling. Jun 02, 2015 i just finished rereading the book last night. Nov 19, 2015 but the last scenewhich accomplishes everything the books achingly romantic ending does without a line of dialogueis a corker. Patricia highsmith got the idea for carol or the price of salt as it was named originally shortly after her first novel, strangers on a train was published. In carol s case, these obstacles are the prejudices of the time and culture they live in. The brilliant subversiveness of carols conventional ending. Replicating the final passage of the stunningly forwardthinking 1952 novel its based on, patricia highsmiths the price of salt, haynes film ends on a shot of carol focusing on her adamantly. The biggest difference between the book and the muppet version of a christmas carol was that the movie had a narrator through the whole show. Jan 06, 2016 in carol, 2 women leap into an unlikely love affair screenwriter phyllis nagy and director todd haynes discuss their new film based on patricia highsmiths 1952 novel, the price of salt. Author patricia highsmith is best known for her psychological thrillers strangers on a train and the talented mr. This free synopsis covers all the crucial plot points of a christmas carol. In 1990, the book was republished by bloomsbury as carol under patricia highsmiths name. As conventional norms of the time challenge their undeniable attraction, an honest story emerges to reveal the resilience of the heart in the face.
People on here are overhyping so much it when its exactly the kind of ending i imagined for a movie like this. Originally, the movie was going to be very true to the book. Carol, based on the patricia highsmith novel the price of salt and one of the most buzzedabout films on the festival circuit this year, is a. Hi guys, i started this thread mostly because i didnt know where to put this question, and it feels like a big one. Inspired designs on tshirts, posters, stickers, home decor, and more by independent artists and designers from around the world. Id read 1 already, didnt have an interest in 1 of them, and 2 were a 4 out of 5 stars to you, the first of a two book thriller and suspense series, written in 2014 by caroline kepnes. A christmas carol adaptations ranked from worst to best. As the day passes, the spirit ages, becoming noticeably older. Nov 20, 2015 then carol, an elegant blonde, appears across the store floor the camera floats past carol, and then reverses back quickly. Solving the many mysteries of what became carol the new york. How does scrooge feel about charity in the end of the book a christmas carol.
Most of the movies i have seen pretty much have the same screenplay it seems, with some small differences in most and some have a scene or two the others dont. The corn maiden and other nightmares by joyce carol oates. The end of it in charles dickenss a christmas carol. Carol star cate blanchett and films director, todd haynes, talked to. Carol full movie s channel, the place to watch all videos, playlists, and live streams by carol full movie on dailymotion. How closely does a christmas carol follow the original charles dickens novel. I immediately wanted to read the book from which it had been based upon. Sarah paulson on having a key scene for her character cut from carol duration. In carol, 2 women leap into an unlikely love affair screenwriter phyllis nagy and director todd haynes discuss their new film based on patricia highsmiths 1952 novel, the price of. The novels ending, however, suggests there is a potential future for the two lovers, with carol s loss of rindy to harge opening the door to a shared life with therese. Well, a christmas carol feels like an ungrimmed fairy talea story with magical creatures and fantastical events, but one that is strictly for grownups, what with its main feature being a really strong sense of existential dread and a fear of other people. In the movie, carol flies back to new york in the night and abby shows up to drive back with therese. Dec 19, 2019 a christmas carol is a dark story, a rather spooky ghost story in large part, but its greatest effect is in illuminating the pain and misery one poor unfortunate soul inflicts on the multitudes. The love affair he had with claire was a forgery built or painted by billy the artist who bids on things for oldman, the mechanic who forged the automaton to intrigue oldman and guided him down the steps of falling in love, the mechanic and clai.
Carol is a film about falling in love, but as patricia white points out in her very smart analysis of the films queerness a lesbian carol for christmas, in their end oftheyear awardsrace rhetoric, too many critics have acclaimed carol as a universal romance, when in fact, the film is deeply queer in its filmic and narrative. A young woman in her 20s, therese belivet, is a clerk working in a manhattan department store and dreaming of a more fulfilling life when she meets carol, an alluring woman trapped in a loveless, convenient marriage. Game of thrones book ending vs got tv finale compared. Highsmithknown as a suspense writer based on her psychological thriller strangers on a trainused an alias because she did not want to be tagged as a lesbianbook writer, and because of the use of her own life references for. Carol is a 2015 romantic melodrama film directed by todd haynes. Highsmith accepted the latter and it was reissued in 1984.
The beginning of carol flashes forward to the end, detailing a fraught meeting between the films title character cate blanchett and therese belivet rooney mara. Then carol, an elegant blonde, appears across the store floor the camera floats past carol, and then reverses back quickly. She lived in new york at the time, was depressed, and in need of money. If you havent seen the movie yet, you might want to hold off on reading this piece until you. Parents need to know that carol is a deeply affecting 1950sset drama starring cate blanchett and rooney mara about love, identity, friendship, sexuality, and marriage that explores mature themes. In analyzing highsmiths novel, haynes hit on a key pointthat a writer. Sie hofft, dass therese sich entscheidet, mit ihr zusammenzuwohnen, doch therese lehnt ihr angebot ab. In the movie it shows a lot more of his liberality at the end of the story. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of a christmas carol and what it means.
She took a job as a sales assistant in a department store and, one day. Fxs a christmas carol certainly brings something new to the triedandtrue story and its worth a watch for that alone. The biggest difference between the muppets movie and the book are scrooges emotions at the end. Cate blanchett and rooney mara in carol impressive scenes part. Therese has no family, but carol is caught in a bitter divorce and custody battle.
This is one of the rare books where the title isnt mentioned in the book aside from the cover page. Carol movie clip getting a tree 2015 rooney mara, cate blanchett movie hd by movieclips coming soon. Carol screenwriter phyllis nagy, friend of patricia highsmith. A message to our movie fans read more gift cards offers. In the end, the dialogue in the film varied between being exactly the same as the book in some scenes, while most scenes had altered dialogue. Nov 21, 2015 does disney give scrooge a second chance. But carol would be better described as a film where feelings run very. Carol movie tiein edition movie tiein editions book 0 kindle edition by patricia highsmith. It plumbs the depths of darkness to the point that even the usually. Why this book my friend medhat asked if id be interested in a buddy read with him and proposed 5 different books. Carol, a film adaptation nominated for six academy awards and nine british academy film awards. Nov 23, 2015 the film and the nature of its leads somewhat clandestine love are, in this case thankfully, far too reserved for a furiously liplocked ending.
Carol is a 2015 romantic drama film directed by todd haynes. Which christmas carol movie is the most faithful to the book. The many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. In carol, 2 women leap into an unlikely love affair. Nov 20, 2015 carol is the most beautiful movie of the year. Set in 1950s new york, two women from very different backgrounds find themselves in the throes of love. Carol movie tiein edition movie tiein editions book 0. The screenplay does diverge from the book in its framing. The game of thrones finale has aired on hbo and now season 8 is up for a number of emmys. Its the early 1950s, and manhattan shopgirl therese belivet rooney mara is on the phone with carol aird cate blanchett, a married socialite who. Nov 19, 2015 carols happy ending the screenwriterand friend of patricia highsmithswho spent almost 20 years struggling to bring the price of salt to theaters.
The most common critique of the book that ive seen from speaking to others. Were talking about the original title, of course, which is the price of salt, not the rerelease title and the title of the film, carol. Guy pearce stars in bbc miniseries that brings a bleak lump of coal to the holidays, with andy serkis and stephen graham. The price of salt later republished under the title carol is a 1952 romance novel by patricia highsmith, first published under the pseudonym claire morgan. In the movie it shows scrooges change and gives more details and examples of his behavior at the end than the book does. A british radio adaptation of the novel was broadcast in 2014. First published in 1952 and touted as the novel of a love that society forbids, the book. At first i didnt like the writing style but quickly got used to it and didnt want to put the book down. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading carol movie tiein edition movie tiein editions book 0. Why todd hayness oscarnominated carol is misunderstood the. Originally published in 1952 under a pseudonym, the price of salt was heralded as the novel. Novelist jill dawson writes about the women behind the book. I think they used the same script for rich littles a christmas carol, a tv special not really a movie. Could carol and therese find a way to be together in the end.
The final girl, a key part of every great slasher movie. The films bookended scenes were the one major change asked for by. The beginning of carol flashes forward to the end, detailing a fraught. The book, which the author prized and later disowned, has been made into a movie starring cate blanchett. Set in new york city during the early 1950s, carol.
Expect lots of periodaccurate smoking and some social drinking in this story that explores the risks and rewards of being true to who you really are. The corn maiden is the gutwrenching story of marissa, a beautiful and sweet elevenyearold girl with hair the color of corn silk. A short summary of charles dickenss a christmas carol. I havent read the book yet, but from what i hear, this is what set it apart from other novels featuring homosexuality from that period. Carol is a 2015 drama film directed by todd haynes. In an adaptation of patricia highsmiths seminal novel the price of salt, carol follows two women from very different backgrounds who find themselves in an unexpected love affair in 1950s new york. Scrooge finds the jovial gathering delightful and pleads with the spirit to stay until the very end of the festivities. An incomparable master storyteller in all forms, in the corn maiden and other nightmares joyce carol oates spins six imaginative tales of suspense. No matter what youre looking for or where you are in the world, our global marketplace of sellers can help you find unique and affordable options. During the movie the narrator would be involed during the whole show. In this updated retelling of dickens a christmas carol, ruthless businesswoman and shopping store owner elizabeth ebbie scrooge is taught the true spirit of christmas by three spirits who visit her.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. But their newly discovered bliss is shattered when carol is forced to choose between her child and her lover. The are a quite a few people out there who think that in the end, therese shouldnt have gone to carol. Book bob says no more until the end of the day when he confirms he would very much like. I recently saw the movie carol and when i found out its based on a book, i was surprised i hadnt heard of it a lesbian classic that had escaped my attention until now. Carol invites therese to her house in new jersey for visits. Why todd hayness oscarnominated carol is misunderstood.
In an adaptation of patricia highsmiths seminal novel the price of salt, carol follows two women from very different backgrounds who find themselves in an. Whether that ending remained intact in the film, i will not say. The movie isnt my typical genre either, but it had been one of the best i had seen for a very long time. For like one of the films central characters, highsmith herself had a penchant for married women. Nov 18, 2015 music, film, tv and political news coverage. Solving the many mysteries of what became carol cate blanchett in a. Wanted to read the book since i just recently saw the movie carol for the first time and fell in love with it. Carol s first scene follows a young man into the bar at the ritz hotel, and as he settles in, he recognizes therese from a distance and. Carol star cate blanchett and films director, todd haynes, talked to buzzfeed news about the movies bold final act. In bringing this book to the screen in his gorgeous new movie carol, todd haynes has, as filmmakers will, changed a few. May, 2015 todd hayness film of highsmiths only openly lesbian novel, carol, is about to premiere in cannes, starring cate blanchett. This is a far cry from my usual genre of book, but i had recently watched the movie.
I almost cried at the last two pages before therese met carol again in elysee. What happens in the ending of the movie the best offer. Its because of this that some critics have called the movie. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Nov, 2015 what ends up defining filmcarol, however, beyond her incontrovertible perfection, is the movies plot, which focuses on and teases out her actionsmany of which are only implicit in the book. What describes scrooge at the end of a christmas carol. The film stars cate blanchett, rooney mara, sarah paulson, jake lacy, and kyle chandler. Solving the many mysteries of what became carol the. The screenplay by phyllis nagy is based on the 1952 romance novel the price of salt by patricia. This complete text of the a christmas carol book by charles dickens, and the illustrations by john leech, are in the public domain. Jan 15, 2016 its a tale of intimacy and repression that dares to imagine a happy ending. Gender in the modern horror film, to refer to the last girl standing at the end of a horror movie. Personally, i think its one of the best love stories ever written because of complexity about love against norms within simplicity about two people who are deeply in love.
The book just had the narrator in th ebeginning of each seen. The movie finds something erotic everywhere in the surfaces, the tailoring, the furnishing and of course the. Cate blanchett in a scene from the coming film carol, based on the novel the price of salt by patricia highsmith. All the dialogue was kept the same and almost the entire movie was going to be from the perspective of elizabeth like the book. Etsy is the home to thousands of handmade, vintage, and oneofakind products and gifts related to your search. Their first interaction is businesslike, but in reality it is a flirtatious scene, pierced with the thrill of danger. Carol star cate blanchett and films director, todd haynes, talked to buzzfeed news about the movie s bold final act. Carol offers a rare ending for a lesbian romance buzzfeed.
Dec 25, 20 a christmas carol is a short story, not very long at all as i read it today and found some interesting differences between the book by dickens and the movie incantations. My first public acting and they threw me in the deep end. Disneys mickeys christmas carol 1983 alternate ending. But highsmiths novel upended that expectation, and haynes movie. In this adaptation of the novel the price of salt by patricia highsmith, therese rooney mara, a young departmentstore clerk in 1950s manhattan, meets carol cate blanchett, a beautiful older.
51 927 1305 40 841 1153 718 277 1298 758 1154 255 242 471 1482 663 817 155 688 875 801 1530 844 1295 233 1474 768 426 1440 388 641 173